Blokz Journal / Explainers / Guides
Crypto ETFs: how spot bitcoin and ether ETFs work
AbstractHow spot bitcoin and ether ETFs are built, how shares are created and redeemed, who holds the coins, what the SEC reviews, and what fund documents disclose.
KeywordsGuides; Crypto ETFs; Crypto Regulation
A spot bitcoin or ether exchange-traded fund (ETF) is a security that trades on a stock exchange and aims to track the market price of the underlying crypto asset. The fund holds the actual coins, not futures contracts, through a custodian. Investors buy and sell shares through an ordinary brokerage account, and they never handle a private key or a wallet. The shares, not the coins, are the thing they own.
These products are often called ETFs, but the more precise label for most of them is exchange-traded product (ETP), because they are structured as grantor trusts or similar vehicles that hold a commodity-like asset rather than as funds registered under the Investment Company Act of 1940. That difference shapes the rules they follow, how they are regulated by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), and what protections investors have. This guide explains how the structure works from sponsor to shareholder.
In brief
- A spot crypto ETP holds the underlying asset, which is kept by a custodian, and issues shares that trade on a national securities exchange.
- Authorized participants, usually large broker-dealers, create and redeem shares in large blocks, which keeps the share price close to the value of the holdings.
- The sponsor charges a fee, which is deducted from the trust’s assets.
- The SEC regulates the offering through registration statements and regulates listing through exchange rule filings or generic listing standards.
- Investors face crypto price risk, custody risk, tracking differences, and premiums or discounts to net asset value.
Spot versus futures products
A futures-based crypto ETF holds regulated futures contracts rather than the asset. Futures products were available before spot products because the SEC had reviewed them under the Investment Company Act, and the underlying futures trade on CFTC-regulated markets. Their returns can differ from the spot price because of how futures contracts are priced and rolled from one expiry to the next.
A spot product holds the asset itself. That gives a tighter link to the price, but it requires the trust to arrange custody, and for the exchange to show that the market for the asset is resistant to fraud and manipulation. That last point, and not the fund’s mechanics, was the main sticking point for years.
How the US got spot products
The SEC for years disapproved exchange applications to list spot bitcoin products, citing concerns that the underlying market was vulnerable to manipulation and that exchanges had not shown enough surveillance-sharing arrangements. In 2023 the US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit ruled in a case brought by Grayscale that the SEC had treated spot bitcoin products inconsistently with futures products. Spot bitcoin products were approved for listing in January 2024, and spot ether products followed later in 2024.
In 2025 the SEC approved generic listing standards for commodity-based trust shares for the exchanges that proposed them. Under those standards, a qualifying product can list without a separate rule-change approval, so long as it meets listed conditions, which relate to surveillance and to the presence of related futures markets or other listed products. Products that do not qualify must still file a rule change under Section 19(b) of the Exchange Act and Rule 19b-4. The SEC and exchanges post the orders and rule filings on their sites; readers should consult them for the conditions.
A listing standard is not the same as approval of the offering. The trust still needs an effective registration statement under the Securities Act, and the SEC’s staff reviews that disclosure.
The structure, step by step
Sponsor. A company, often an asset manager, forms the trust, files the registration statement and charges a sponsor fee. The sponsor appoints the other parties.
Trust. A legal entity, typically a Delaware statutory trust, that owns the crypto asset. Its only business is to hold the asset, pay expenses and issue shares. It generally does not use leverage, trade or lend the asset, though fund documents describe any exceptions.
Custodian. An entity that holds the private keys that control the asset. Many trusts use a regulated custodian, and many fund documents also describe sub-custodians and cold storage arrangements. Our guide on crypto custody rules covers what regulation applies.
Authorized participants (APs). Large broker-dealers that deal directly with the trust. They deliver the underlying asset or cash in exchange for newly created shares, or hand back shares to redeem the asset or cash.
Exchange. The venue where shares trade throughout the day, such as a national securities exchange.
Index or pricing source. The trust values its holdings using a reference rate or index, built from prices on a set of crypto exchanges. The prospectus describes how the benchmark is built and what happens if it is unavailable.
Transfer agent and administrator. Maintain the share register and calculate net asset value (NAV).
Creation and redemption
The mechanism that keeps an ETP’s price near the value of its holdings is creation and redemption.
When demand for shares pushes the market price above NAV, an authorized participant can buy the underlying asset, deliver it to the trust and receive new shares, which it sells at the higher market price. That adds supply and pulls the price back toward NAV. When the shares trade below NAV, the AP can buy shares, return them to the trust and receive the asset or cash worth more than it paid. Competition among APs keeps the gap small in normal markets.
Creations and redemptions can take two forms. In a cash model, the AP delivers cash and the sponsor or an agent buys the asset. In an in-kind model, the AP delivers the asset itself. The method affects costs, tax treatment for the AP and operational risk. Prospectuses state which model a trust uses, and whether it has changed over time.
Fees, NAV and premium or discount
Investors pay a sponsor fee, expressed as an annual percentage of assets, which the trust pays by selling a small amount of the asset. They also pay brokerage commissions where applicable and bear the bid-ask spread when trading. A higher fee reduces the return relative to the asset, so a spot product will lag the coin’s price by roughly the fee, plus other costs.
NAV is the value of the trust’s holdings per share, calculated daily from the benchmark. The market price of a share can be above (a premium) or below (a discount) NAV during the day. Funds publish daily NAV and premium or discount information on their websites, which the listing standards require for commodity-based trust shares, according to law-firm summaries of the 2025 order.
Regulation: what applies and what does not
Because these trusts generally are not registered investment companies, investors do not get the protections of the Investment Company Act, such as limits on leverage, independent board requirements and custody rules for funds. Instead, protections come from:
- The Securities Act of 1933, which requires registration of the shares and disclosure of risks, custody arrangements, fees, conflicts and the benchmark.
- The Securities Exchange Act of 1934, which governs trading, exchange listing, ongoing reporting through annual and quarterly reports, and market-manipulation rules.
- Exchange rules and the listing standards, which require holdings and NAV data to be public.
- The CFTC’s anti-fraud and anti-manipulation authority over commodity markets, to the extent the asset is a commodity.
The SEC’s 2026 interpretive release classifies crypto assets that function as digital commodities as not securities in themselves. A trust that holds such an asset is a security because the shares are securities, even though the asset it holds is not. That distinction explains why the SEC reviews the offering and why the CFTC remains relevant to the underlying market.
Risks to understand
Price volatility. The asset can lose most of its value. The ETP does not hedge it.
Custody and operational risk. Loss or theft of private keys, or failure of a custodian, would reduce the trust’s assets. Insurance, if any, is limited and described in the prospectus.
Market manipulation and fragmentation. The underlying spot market trades across many venues, and prices may differ.
Tracking difference. Fees, timing of NAV and any trust expenses create gaps.
Concentration among APs and custodians. If few firms perform key roles, disruption at one of them can have a large effect.
Regulatory and tax uncertainty. Rules can change. Investors should read the prospectus and consult a tax professional.
A worked example
The figures below are hypothetical.
A trust holds 1,000 coins and has 100,000 shares outstanding, so each share represents 0.01 coin, before fees. The benchmark values a coin at $50,000 at the 4 p.m. pricing time. The trust’s gross assets are $50 million. After accrued fees of $10,000 for the day, NAV is $49.99 million, or $499.90 per share.
During the day, strong demand pushes the share price to $503. An AP sees the premium of about 0.6 percent. It buys 100 coins on the spot market, delivers them to the trust in return for 10,000 new shares, and sells the shares on the exchange at about $503 each, earning the difference less its costs. The new shares increase supply, and the premium shrinks. At the end of the day, the trust holds 1,100 coins and 110,000 shares, and each share still represents just under 0.01 coin because the fee is deducted from the trust’s assets.
FAQ
Do I own bitcoin if I own a spot bitcoin ETF?
No. You own shares in a trust that owns bitcoin. You cannot withdraw the coin or use it for payments through the fund.
Are crypto ETFs registered under the 1940 Act?
Most spot products are structured as commodity trusts rather than registered investment companies, so Investment Company Act protections do not apply. Check each prospectus.
Why do shares sometimes trade away from NAV?
Supply and demand during the day can move the price away from NAV, especially when the underlying market is closed to the benchmark or volatile. Authorized participants arbitrage the gap, but costs can limit how closely they do so.
How do I find a fund’s holdings and fees?
Read the prospectus on EDGAR and the sponsor’s website, which publish holdings, NAV, fees and risk factors.
Does the SEC endorse these products?
No. SEC registration is about disclosure. The agency does not guarantee accuracy or evaluate investment merit.
References
- SEC: Application of the Federal Securities Laws to Certain Types of Crypto Assets and Certain Transactions Involving Crypto Assets, Release Nos. 33-11412; 34-105020, sec.gov.
- SEC: Exchange Act Rule 19b-4 and self-regulatory organization rule filings, sec.gov.
- SEC EDGAR: company filings search, sec.gov.
Prepared with AI assistance from the documents in the references and reviewed under our editorial policy. Not investment advice.