Blokz Journal / Explainers / Guides
When is a crypto asset a security? The Howey test explained
AbstractHow the Howey test decides whether a crypto asset is a security, how SEC staff applied it, and what the SEC's 2026 interpretation says about asset categories.
KeywordsGuides; Crypto Regulation; Securities Law
Whether a crypto asset is a security is the question that decides which regulator, which disclosure rules and which registration requirements apply. The answer rarely turns on the technology. It turns on the facts of how the asset was offered and sold, and the test courts and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) use is more than seventy years old: the Howey test, which asks whether a transaction is an “investment contract.”
Understanding that test explains most of the public arguments about crypto regulation. It also explains why an asset can be treated differently at different moments, and why regulators have moved from case-by-case analysis toward written categories. This guide covers the test, how the SEC applied it to digital assets, what its 2026 interpretation changed, and the vocabulary readers will meet in SEC releases.
In brief
- The Securities Act and Exchange Act define “security” broadly, and the definition includes an “investment contract.”
- The Howey test asks whether there is an investment of money in a common enterprise with a reasonable expectation of profits from the efforts of others.
- The test looks at substance over labels. Calling something a “token” or “coin” does not decide the outcome.
- The SEC’s 2019 staff framework was later marked withdrawn on the SEC website, superseded by a March 2026 interpretive release that sorts crypto assets into five categories.
- Even an asset that is not itself a security can be sold as part of an investment contract.
Where the test comes from
In SEC v. W.J. Howey Co., decided in 1946, the Supreme Court considered a Florida company that sold interests in citrus groves together with service contracts under which the company cultivated and marketed the fruit. Buyers were mostly out-of-state investors with no farming experience. The Court held that the arrangement was an investment contract, and therefore a security, and set out a definition that courts still apply: a contract, transaction or scheme in which a person invests money in a common enterprise and is led to expect profits solely from the efforts of the promoter or a third party. Later decisions loosened “solely” to mean primarily or significantly.
The significance of Howey is its flexibility. Congress wrote the securities laws broadly so they would reach new schemes, and the Court has described the test as one of economic reality. A crypto token can be an investment contract in one sale and not in another, depending on what the seller promised and what the buyers reasonably expected.
The elements applied to crypto assets
SEC staff published a framework in April 2019 that walked through how the Howey elements apply to digital assets. The SEC’s website now marks that document as withdrawn and superseded by the 2026 interpretation described below, and the page notes the framework was never a Commission rule or statement. It remains useful for understanding how the analysis was structured, and readers should treat it as history rather than current guidance.
Investment of money. This is usually met when a buyer gives value for the asset, whether in dollars, another digital asset or other consideration. The staff framework noted that the lack of a cash payment, as in a bounty or airdrop, does not by itself defeat this element.
Common enterprise. The framework observed that this element typically exists for digital assets, because buyers’ fortunes are tied together or tied to the promoter’s efforts.
Reasonable expectation of profits from the efforts of others. This is usually the contested element. The framework asked whether buyers rely on an active participant, such as a development team or promoter, to perform essential managerial work: building the network, controlling supply, making governance decisions or managing how proceeds are used. It also asked whether buyers are expecting a return from price appreciation or distributions, which marketing and secondary trading can reinforce.
The framework also listed features that make an investment contract less likely: a network that is fully operational, an asset that people can use for its intended function, sales in quantities consistent with use rather than speculation, and value tied to the goods or services it provides.
What the 2026 interpretation says
In March 2026 the SEC issued an interpretive release titled “Application of the Federal Securities Laws to Certain Types of Crypto Assets and Certain Transactions Involving Crypto Assets” (Release Nos. 33-11412 and 34-105020, File No. S7-2026-09), which also carries guidance from the Commodity Futures Trading Commission. It sorts crypto assets into five categories:
- Digital commodities.
- Digital collectibles.
- Digital tools.
- Stablecoins.
- Digital securities, also called tokenized securities.
According to the release, digital commodities, collectibles and tools are not securities themselves, although any of them can be sold subject to an investment contract. Stablecoins may or may not be securities depending on their characteristics. Digital securities, which are traditional financial instruments formatted as or represented by crypto assets, are securities. The release states that a security is a security regardless of whether it is issued or represented offchain or onchain.
Two features of this structure matter for readers. First, the release separates the asset from the transaction. A digital commodity can be the subject of an investment contract if a seller makes promises of managerial effort that lead buyers to expect profits. Second, that status is not permanent. Law-firm summaries of the release describe it as saying the investment-contract relationship can end when the issuer fulfills or publicly abandons the promises, after which later secondary-market trades fall outside the securities laws. Readers should consult the release itself for the exact standard.
The release became effective on March 23, 2026, according to the text on the SEC’s website. Our guide on tokenized securities and the SEC looks at the fifth category in more detail.
Who is involved
The SEC enforces the Securities Act of 1933 and the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. Its Division of Corporation Finance reviews offerings and disclosures, and its Division of Enforcement brings cases. The SEC’s Strategic Hub for Innovation and Financial Technology (FinHub) issued the 2019 framework.
The CFTC regulates commodity derivatives and has asserted authority over fraud and manipulation in some commodity spot markets. The 2026 release includes CFTC guidance, and the CFTC said it would administer the Commodity Exchange Act consistently with it.
Courts decide disputed cases. District courts have applied Howey to crypto sales in different ways, which is part of why regulators wanted a written statement.
Congress has considered market-structure legislation that would assign roles to the SEC and CFTC. Until a statute passes, the agencies rely on existing law and interpretation.
Issuers, exchanges and brokers are the parties who must decide whether registration or an exemption is needed, and whether their activity requires registration as an exchange, broker-dealer or transfer agent.
Key terms
Investment contract. The category of security at the center of the test.
Active participant. The framework’s term for a promoter, sponsor, developer or other person or group that performs the essential managerial efforts.
Registration. Securities offered to the public must either be registered with the SEC or qualify for an exemption, such as Regulation D or Regulation A. Registration brings disclosure obligations that continue after the sale.
Secondary market. Trading between holders after the original sale. The question of when a secondary trade involves a security is a core dispute in crypto cases.
Airdrop. A free distribution of tokens. The framework said it can still satisfy the investment element, depending on what recipients give up or do.
A worked example
The following scenario is hypothetical and meant only to show how the analysis proceeds.
A startup announces a new blockchain and sells a native token to the public before the network exists. The marketing says the team will build the network, list the token on exchanges and burn tokens to reduce supply, and that early buyers will benefit as adoption grows. Buyers pay in dollars and ether.
- Investment of money: met, since buyers paid value.
- Common enterprise: present, since buyers’ outcomes depend on the same team’s success.
- Expectation of profits from others’ efforts: strongly suggested, since the promises concern managerial efforts that buyers expect to raise the token’s value.
Under that analysis, the sales look like an investment contract, and the issuer would need registration or an exemption. Now suppose, years later, the network is live, the code is open source and no one controls it, the issuer has completed or publicly abandoned its promised work, and the token is used to pay fees. Under the approach the 2026 release describes, a later purchase on an exchange from another holder may no longer involve an investment contract, because the buyer cannot reasonably view the issuer’s old promises as attached to the token. The issuer’s original sales, however, can still be examined for the period when promises were outstanding.
Common misconceptions
“If a token has utility, it is not a security.” Utility is a factor, not a trump card. An asset with some use can still be sold with promises that create an investment contract.
“A token is a security or it isn’t, forever.” The 2026 release and the earlier framework both turn on facts that can change, such as the maturity of the network and the status of the issuer’s promises.
“Decentralization is a legal safe harbor.” The word appears in analysis, but the SEC’s release describes the question in terms of how the issuer’s own promises are fulfilled. Check the release for the standard.
“The CFTC and SEC do the same thing.” They have different statutes. A digital commodity can fall under the CFTC’s remit while an investment contract involving it falls under the SEC’s.
“No-action letters are law.” Staff letters and statements bind only the staff’s enforcement position on the facts presented. They are not Commission rules.
FAQ
Is bitcoin a security?
The SEC’s 2026 release puts native network assets in the category of digital commodities, which are not securities by themselves, according to law-firm summaries of its examples. Check the release’s text for the specific assets it names.
What if a token was sold before the network launched?
The initial sale can still be an investment contract if the seller made promises that led buyers to expect profit from managerial efforts. That is the scenario the Howey test was built to catch.
Does the test apply to NFTs?
It applies to any asset. The 2026 release describes digital collectibles, such as NFTs with limited functionality, as generally not securities, but notes that structures relying on managerial efforts, such as fractionalized interests, can be investment contracts.
Where do stablecoins fit?
The release treats them as fact-specific. Payment stablecoins as defined in the GENIUS Act are excluded from the securities definition by statute, according to summaries of the release.
Where can I read the official materials?
The SEC posts the release and the withdrawn framework on sec.gov, and the Investor.gov glossary explains investment contracts for general readers.
References
- SEC: Framework for "Investment Contract" Analysis of Digital Assets (withdrawn), sec.gov.
- SEC: Application of the Federal Securities Laws to Certain Types of Crypto Assets and Certain Transactions Involving Crypto Assets, Release Nos. 33-11412; 34-105020, sec.gov.
- Investor.gov: Investment contract (glossary), investor.gov.
Prepared with AI assistance from the documents in the references and reviewed under our editorial policy. Not investment advice.